My Classmates Thought I Failed The Rankings, So I Posted The Military School Notice

Chapter 316 A Pair Of Thirty-Four, A Winning Debate

The opposite side has already made a rebuttal.

Then it's Jiang Ge's turn.

Debate debate, no debate, how can there be discussion.

Several of the members looked at Jiang Ge anxiously.

They just agree with Jiang Ge's proposal and point of view.

But this does not mean that you can refute the other party's point of view.

This not only requires a very solid knowledge of military theory.

It is also necessary to study a point of view very thoroughly.

On the contrary, Feng Shaohua was sitting there~ staring at the front without moving.

He heard Jiang Ge's point of view at noon yesterday - after.

Then go through your own judgment.

Standing here very firmly.

Rebutting the other side may - not help much.

But holding a personal field is absolutely no problem.

See the smile on Jiang Ge's face.

Yang Fengrui raised his hand to signal him to continue.

Jiang Ge nodded.

"I personally disagree with the point of view put forward by Chief Zhao Peilong just now.

"First of all, for a commander, too much consideration affects the core elements of command.

"These can't be considered after rushing to the battlefield."

"It's that all factors have to be taken into account before a full-blown war breaks out.

"The overall planning of the war command before the war was considered from all aspects."

"It is impossible to put aside any issues that affect the core aspects of operational command."

"All combat deployments, including the combat area, combat environment, and combat terrain."

"Whether the definition of war is a war of aggression or a war of defense."

"These have to be fully deployed before the troops go out."

"Only in this way can we ensure that all combat troops quickly enter the combat state after arriving on the battlefield."

"If the fighter plane is delayed because of too much consideration."

"Then I can only say that the pre-war preparations were insufficient."

"If the battle deployment is carried out in advance, the location of the command post and the channels used to transmit information are all unavoidable.

"Without the corresponding command information and tools, it is difficult for a commander to carry out command on the command object.

"The combat command will be difficult to carry on."

"And according to the principle of independence of dividing elements, elements should not include or overlap each other.

"The combat arrangements deployed in advance have taken this aspect into consideration."

"Then we can't directly remove this aspect during the battle."

"The method of pre-war deployment belongs to the product of the organic combination and interaction of the subjective initiative of the command and the technical equipment of the command.

"It is more reflected in the subjective initiative of the commander, and it is the human factor in the command tool.

"When carrying out various combat plans, all factors have been taken into consideration.

"And made a detailed and meticulous plan."

"It's nothing more than not thinking about the command environment, command tools and command methods after arriving on the battlefield.

"Because these have been fully planned."

"If it's time to make these plans on the battlefield, then there will be no need to fight this battle."

"Take what has been planned and discard part of the factors."

"I disagree with that view."

"Operational command refers to the planning and dispatching activities conducted by the commander on the preparation and implementation of the operations of the troops under his command.

"None of these activities just happened in a vacuum."

"There needs to be a certain amount of space and time to support it."

"Then this time and space support, but at the same time, those three conditions cannot be avoided."

"Why do these three conditions have to be bypassed when it comes to discussing the core factors affecting operational command on the battlefield.

"My opinion is over, thank you all."

Jiang Ge's voice just fell.

Jiang Xu.

That is, the brigade commander of the 77th Group Military Industry and Chemical Brigade stood up directly.

"The pre-war preparations you just mentioned.

"These are not unique to the interior after arriving on the battlefield, but external things.

"It's already prepared."

"It is the external condition for the occurrence of the objective thing of combat command activities."

"We cannot treat this external thing as an essential element within operational command.

"Although environmental content has constraints and influences on operational command."

"It affects the commander's selection of combat targets, the use of troops, and the use of tactics."

"These are the basis and essential conditions for commanders to make operational decisions, plan and organize, coordinate and control activities.

"I admit all of this."

"However, the role or influence of environmental content on combat command is expressed in the form of information."

"A commander directs the soldiers to fight. As for the battlefield environment and the command environment, these have little influence on the commander."

"It can even be said that there is no need to think about it."

"Because the commander's responsibility is to coordinate the overall situation, not to charge forward."

"Environmental content can only play its due role if it is mastered by the commander in the form of information."

"Therefore, I think it is barely acceptable to use environmental factors as the form of expression."

"But by itself it cannot be used as a command element."

"Terrain and environment can be used as elements of combat.

"That doesn't mean it can be an element of command."

"So my point of view is that there are only three combat elements, the commander, the commanded and the intermediary between the command.

"Other factors cannot become the core factors affecting operational command."

"My point is over, thank you all."

All the officers present were a little dumbfounded after hearing the debate between the two sides.

I always feel when Jiang Ge said it.

I feel that Jiang Ge's point of view is reasonable and correct.

But it was Zhao Peilong and Jiang Xu's turn to refute.

I also feel that people's rebuttals are correct.

All of a sudden.

Many people don't know how to make a specific judgment.

I was still very confident in the original support point of view.

But as the debate continued to escalate.

Attitudes are beginning to be a little ambiguous.

Vice President Yang Fengrui didn't express anything after seeing this situation.

Academic research itself is like this.

If an academic point of view is easily denied.

Where are the arguments and controversies?

In the process of any point of view and topic being recognized, various examples will be extended.

It needs to be confirmed and answered.

if not.

Doesn't that mean that what any expert or professor says has become the truth.

After Jiang Ge listened to Jiang Xu's point of view.

He did not choose not to refute his point of view just because the two belonged to the same war zone.

Not to mention that the other party was the brigade commander of the industrial and chemical brigade and did not flinch.

………… Ask for flowers…

Of course.

No two people with the same surname.

He said directly: "The chief said that both terrain and environment can be used as elements of combat, and can also be used as factors that affect combat."

"But it can't be an element that affects command."

"I disagree with that."

"Under modern conditions, with the wide application and continuous development of high-tech.

"The role of the command medium is becoming increasingly prominent."

"The chief also said just now that the combat medium, the commander, and the commanded are the core elements that affect command.

"Then now the operational command has higher and higher requirements and dependence on the command medium."

"The forms of expression also show diversity with the development of the times."

"Especially now that electromagnetic technology is widely used in combat."

"If your combat medium suffers from electromagnetic interference during a war, does this mean that one of the elements affecting the command core has been paralyzed?"

"Then at this time, the enemy army can directly lock the position of the headquarters in the shortest time based on the electronic lock."

"I lost the medium of command, and was locked on the command post by the enemy.

"The commander and the commanded will lose contact in a short period of time."

"At this time, any command method, any command environment, and any command tool can be used."

"As long as the entire army can react quickly and make a countermeasure."

"Any method is available."

"Now it's meaningless to talk about what is unique to the outside or what is held internally.

"As long as the command system can be restored quickly, any means will do."

"I really can't think of any reason to exclude the command environment, command means and command tools from the core factors of command.

"Okay, my point is over, thank you everyone."

Jiang Ge finished his opinion.

Quietly stood in the position.

He looked at everyone present with a calm expression.

Already ready for the next round of rebuttals.

But after the thirty-four people sitting on the other side whispered a few words.

No one stood up.

Even Ding Yuan, Zhao Peilong, and Jiang Xu sat quietly in their seats after discussing with each other for a few words.

No one stood up.

On the views he wrote.

Not to mention that the thirty-four students from the training class came to refute him.

Even with the addition of a few visiting professors from the Joint Warfare Academy.

Jiang Ge is also not afraid.

God-level memory plus god-level comprehension.

And the massive knowledge rewarded by the system.

And he himself has been sorting out and studying continuously during this period of time.

He has the confidence to stand here alone against a hundred people.

It may not necessarily win in terms of academic arguments.

But it will never lose.

Stand there for two minutes straight.

No one stood up on the opposite side.

Yang Fengrui knocked on the table.

"The student on the right, do you have any ideas?"

"If there is no rebuttal point of view, then more than 30 of you this time are equivalent to agreeing with Comrade Jiang Ge's point of view.

"Our debate this morning is coming to an end."

"Is there anyone else who wants to stand up and refute?"